Championing
Wellbeing

Sainsbury’s manager succeeds in disability discrimination claim after being left out of International Men’s Day LinkedIn post

Case Summaries, Employment Law

What happened? 

The Claimant had worked for Sainsbury’s for more than 30 years and was a Store Manager in Pontypridd. In July 2022, he went off sick with anxiety and remained absent from work for an extended period. 

During his absence, his line manager, Matt Hourihan, published an International Men’s Day post on LinkedIn and Sainsbury’s internal platform, Yammer. The post celebrated the male leaders in his region and included photographs, names and tags for the male Store Managers in the team. 

The Claimant was the only male Store Manager not included. 

The Claimant argued that being omitted left him feeling excluded, humiliated and caused further distress while he was already absent due to anxiety. He also brought claims in relation to his dismissal for absence related reasons.  

What claims were brought and what was decided? 

The Claimant brought a number of claims, including: 

  • Direct disability discrimination 
  • Discrimination arising from disability 
  • Harassment related to disability 
  • Unfair dismissal 

The Employment Tribunal dismissed almost all of the claims. The Tribunal found that many of the Claimant’s concerns about absence management meetings, Occupational Health referrals and comments made by his manager were either unsupported by the evidence or were reasonable management actions in the circumstances and that ultimately his dismissal was not discriminatory or unfair.  

However, the Tribunal upheld two claims relating to the International Men’s Day post: 

  • Harassment related to disability 
  • Discrimination arising from disability under section 15 Equality Act 2010 

The Tribunal found that the decision not to include the Claimant was connected to his sickness absence, which arose from his disability. The omission was therefore related to disability and amounted to unfavourable treatment. The Tribunal accepted that the Claimant reasonably felt humiliated by being excluded from a post celebrating male leaders in the business whilst every other male Store Manager was included.  

Interestingly, the Tribunal also accepted that the manager’s intention was not to upset the Claimant. The manager said he was trying to avoid unwanted contact during the Claimant’s sickness absence. Nevertheless, good intentions did not prevent the treatment from being discriminatory.  

Value 

Following a separate remedy hearing, the Claimant was awarded £11,852, including £7,500 for injury to feelings.  

What does this mean for employers? 

This case is a useful reminder that decisions made with good intentions can still create legal risk. 

The manager genuinely believed he was protecting the Claimant by leaving him out of the post. The Tribunal accepted that explanation. The problem was that the practical effect of the decision was to single the Claimant out from his peers because he was absent due to a disability. 

Many employers actively celebrate teams and individuals on social media and internal communication platforms. Before doing so, it is worth thinking carefully about whether employees who are absent due to sickness, disability, maternity leave or other protected reasons are being treated consistently with colleagues. 

The Tribunal was particularly influenced by the fact that every other male Store Manager was included, while the Claimant was not. 

Top lessons for employers 

  • Consider how employees on sickness absence are represented in workplace communications. 
  • Avoid excluding absent employees from recognition initiatives without carefully considering the potential impact. 
  • Remember that good intentions are not always a defence to discrimination claims. 
  • Assess both the reason for a decision and how it is likely to be perceived by the affected employee. 
  • Train managers on the risks that can arise from social media and internal communications. 

How can Thrive Law help? 

Our employment law team supports employers with disability management, absence processes, workplace investigations and discrimination risk. We can also help review internal communications and manager decision-making where sensitive employee situations arise. 

Conclusion 

Although most of the Claimant’s claims failed, a single social media post resulted in findings of disability-related harassment and discrimination. The case demonstrates how seemingly small decisions can have significant consequences when they affect employees who are absent because of a disability. 

If you would like advice on managing long-term sickness absence, disability-related issues or discrimination risks, get in touch with the Thrive Law team. 

References 

Judgment:
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/Employment_Tribunal_Judgment_Mr_D_Cooper_v_Sainsburys_Supermarkets_Ltd___Other_1600755_2023 

BBC article:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cpv839vlrpwo [t.co] 

Contact Us

Contact Form (Generic)
Thrive Law is committed to protecting and respecting your privacy, and we’ll only use your personal information to administer your account and to provide the products and services you requested from us. From time to time, we would like to contact you about our products and services, as well as other content that may be of interest to you. If you consent to us contacting you for this purpose, please tick below to say how you would like us to contact you:
To respond to your enquiry, we need to collect and use your personal data. Please confirm that you have read and understood our Privacy Policy by ticking the box below.

Book a Free Consultation

Our Awards and Recognition

Verified by MonsterInsights