What happened?
The Claimant had worked for Kirklees Council since 1973. From 1998 onwards he was released full time from his day job to act as Branch Secretary for the local UNISON branch. In late 2019, two serious complaints were made against him. One alleged he had clenched his fists and threatened a colleague during a meeting. The other alleged a long pattern of bullying, intimidation, and manipulative behaviour towards colleagues, some of it going back years.
An independent investigator was brought in, but the investigation was poorly handled. The Council’s Head of People Services never gave the investigator clear terms of reference, and the first draft report was described by the Tribunal as unclear and poorly structured. The Head of People had then commented on the draft, and some of the language changed as a result of her comments, including a finding that went from “insufficient evidence” of a threat, to demonstrative “threatening behaviour.”
That history became central to the Claimant’s case. He argued his employer had used misconduct allegations as cover to get rid of a difficult trade union figure, and that HR had steered the investigation to reach a particular conclusion.
What claims were brought and what was decided?
The Claimant brought a claim for unfair dismissal, including a claim that his dismissal was automatically unfair because the real reason was his trade union activity. He also brought a trade union detriment claim.
The original Tribunal dismissed the claim on all matters. It found that a separate manager, not the Head of People Services, made the decision to bring disciplinary charges. It found that the dismissing officer made his own independent decision, based on the evidence, and would have dismissed for the threat allegation alone even without the bullying allegation. It also found that although the Claimant’s conduct happened in the context of his trade union role, it was “wholly unreasonable and extraneous” to that role, so it fell outside the legal protection given to trade union activities.
The Claimant appealed to the Employment Appeal Tribunal on the grounds that the conclusion was perverse. This failed too; the EAT held that the Tribunal had properly considered the age of some allegations, had correctly distinguished HR involvement here from cases where HR improperly influences a disciplinary outcome, and had been entitled to find that threatening a colleague and bullying others was conduct genuinely separate from trade union duties, even though it happened while the Claimant was carrying those duties out.
What this means for employers
This case is a reminder that trade union status is not a shield against a fair disciplinary process. Employees carrying out trade union duties are protected from dismissal because of that activity, but they are not protected from the consequences of conduct that crosses a clear line, even if it happens in a trade union context.
It also shows how closely Tribunals will look at the relationship between HR and the decision maker. HR reviewing and commenting on an investigation report is not automatically a problem; what matters is whether HR is genuinely trying to improve the accuracy and clarity of a report, or whether HR is steering the outcome and the eventual decision maker. Here, the Tribunal was satisfied it was the former, partly because different people made the decision to bring the allegations forward, chair the disciplinary hearing, and hear the appeal.
Age of allegations matters too. Old complaints can still support a fair dismissal if the evidence stands up and the process around them is fair, but employers should expect the Tribunal to scrutinise exactly what the employee knew about the case against them and when.
Employers often worry that disciplining a trade union rep will automatically look like retaliation for them in that role. This case shows the protection has limits. Get your process right, keep HR’s role to improving quality rather than shaping outcomes, and use separate decision makers at each stage, and a fair dismissal can stand even where the employee has a trade union role.
Top lessons for employers
- Give investigators clear written terms of reference from the outset. A vague or poorly scoped investigation creates avoidable risk.
- Keep HR’s involvement in an investigation report focused on accuracy and clarity, not on shaping the conclusion.
- Use different people throughout any process, where possible; separation of roles was central to this employer succeeding.
- Trade union activity is protected, but conduct that is genuinely separable from that activity, such as threats or bullying, is not automatically shielded just because it happened in a union context.
- Where allegations span several years, be ready to explain why they are still being relied on and give the employee a fair chance to respond to specifics, not just generalities.
How can Thrive Law help?
We regularly advise employers on running fair, defensible disciplinary and investigation processes, including in the trickier territory of trade union relationships. If you are dealing with a complex misconduct case involving a union representative, or want a second pair of eyes on an investigation before it goes further, we are happy to help.
Conclusion
The EAT’s decision confirms that fair process, clear separation of roles, and solid evidence will usually see an employer through, even in a case with union sensitivities. Cutting corners on any of those three is where employers get into trouble.
Read the judgment: Holmes v Kirklees Council [2026] EAT 80 Original Employment Tribunal decision: https://www.gov.uk/employment-tribunal-decisions/mr-p-holmes-v-kirklees-council-1800365-slash-2022








